Kitchen Experiment: Making My Own Sauerkraut (With Step-by-Step Pictures!)

I have been enjoying real, fermented sauerkraut this past week. There are apparently a number of reasons why eating real fermented vegetables might be real good for you – probiotics, bio-availability of nutrients, yada, yada, yada. Check out this link from Mark’s Daily Apple if you want a good overview of the health benefits. I was just looking for new additions to my low carb diet that could become staples. The problems to this are:

  • A relatively small jar of Bubbies sauerkraut is $4.99. That’s a lot for about 25 cents worth of cabbage. It just bothers me
  • A much larger and cheaper jar of Claussen sauerkraut contains additives ‘to preserve flavor’. I’d rather not do the preservatives – and it’s still way expensive for what is probably 50 cents worth of cabbage.
  • I’d also like to be able to have my sauerkraut made from organic cabbage and avoid pesticide residues and GMOs – but that’s just me.

So I began to research making your own sauerkraut. It seemed kinda easy, only requiring cabbage, a little technique, and a little patience. I found a recipe on and on Mark’s Daily Apple. I also found a link and a video for which offers a nifty-looking kit that I might buy sometime in the future – but I wanted to experiment first.

Briefly, the science as I understand it. Please – if anybody reading this knows more than I do and I got it wrong, please correct me. The cabbage will ferment all by itself just by the naturally occurring bacteria on it. The fermentation process is an anaerobic process, however, so air is bad. The fermentation process, however, will create carbon dioxide gas, so there needs to be a way that gas can escape.

The problem here is that if gas can get out – air can usually get in. This problem requires some creativity on the part of putting the shredded cabbage in the jar. First, you want to keep the cabbage itself under the liquid to keep the air off of it and to ensure it ferments. With the jar open to allow air to escape, however, white mold can or will form as a film on top. This is supposedly harmless and can be skimmed off when it’s done. There’s a huge YUCK! factor to this, of course, and this, I believe, is solved by the Perfect Pickler and its unusual glass tube out the top.

The twisty glass or plastic tube (I don’t know which) can be filled with water and acts like the drain in your kitchen sink. The U in the glass will let gas out, but no air in, which I think keeps the air out, and the mold from growing.

Clever idea – but I wanted to try anyway without. So for this experiment I used:

  1. 1/4 head of organic, locally grown cabbage, with one outer leaf washed and reserved (you’ll see why)
  2. 1/2 teaspoon salt (which ended up being 1.5 tsp)
  3. Old peanut butter jar
  4. French rolling-pin – really just a flat stick
  5. My mandoline – what I consider to be my most dangerous kitchen gadget
It patiently waits for me to be careless...

I first used the mandoline to shred the cabbage, being careful due to the fact that the mandoline, in order to use it, requires you to push your fingers toward a very sharp cutting edge repeatedly. That safety guard they sell it with? They don’t actually intend you to use it – it’s useless – their lawyers just make them put it in the box to defend against the lawsuits from people missing bits of fingertip due to these things.

I placed the shredded cabbage in a bowl, washed it, and drained it as best I could, then I salted it and mixed it about a bit. In one of the instructions, I think, it said to let it stand for a bit, but I don’t follow directions.

Ready to go: my French rolling-pin and peanut butter jar

Now, as the video on the perfect pickler website showed, I placed the cabbage in and pounded it with the end of the French roller:

The phrase 'pounding the cabbage' sounds risqué, doesn't it?

Once all the cabbage has been added, there is the challenge of keeping the cabbage below the level of the liquid. I borrowed a bit from the Perfect Pickler guy, but I’m lazier than him. He uses 2 layers of cabbage leaf, seemingly cut to high precision. Me – I just used the lid of the peanut butter jar to cut out 2 rounds of cabbage leaf.

Cookie-cutting, but with cabbage

This gave me 2 perfectly round cabbage-leaf  ‘covers’ – these would help keep the shredded stuff under the liquid.

Well, as 'perfectly round' as one can make a cabbage leaf...

Now they went into the top of the jar to cover the shredded cabbage.


The next thing was to make sure it was under pressure – pushed down below the line of the liquid. There is also the notion that the liquid will expand, and this also explains why it’s not filled to the top – to leave room for expansion.

To hold the stuff down, I found a little glass ketchup bottle – a mini size, meant for restaurants to give out to individual customers. I put water in and boiled it in the microwave to sterilize it. I knew it was sterilized when I heard a small ‘boom’ in the microwave and saw that the majority of the water had exploded out of the bottle, leaving it mostly empty.

I then put this in the jar on top of my circular leaves. Before doing so, I wiped the sides of the jar to remove the stray cabbage shred, thinking this might reduce the grossness later.

These two are going to be new best friends

Here’s the finished product, with the top only just threaded on so as to allow gasses to escape.

Ready for fermenting

I now had to find a place to put this so it will remain unmolested and at about 68 degrees. The back of my cupboard seemed to be a good place, so it went there.

The next morning, surfing about on the topic still, I noticed I made perhaps a fatal flaw – too little salt. I checked out the jar and honestly, it looked exactly like it did yesterday, and did not seem to smell of anything other than what shredded cabbage would smell like.

While less than ideal, I added another teaspoon, making the total number of teaspoons 1.5. I put the top back on and shook it, which I thought less than ideal, but the best it was going to get – I wasn’t going to take the entire thing out and remix at this point.

One week later I checked out the jar. It looked fine, actually. None of the harmless mold that I was told would form was there. I gave it a sniff – smelled like sauerkraut. I took out the little bottle holding the contents below the liquid line, wiped the inside surface of the glass above the liquid clean just in case there was any mold I couldn’t see, and stuck it in the fridge.

The next day I got up the courage to try it. I briefly thought of googling ‘death by improperly fermented cabbage’ but forged ahead and filled a small bowl with the stuff.

I ate some. Actually, pretty good. The salting was uneven due to my putting in more salt at the last-minute, so some parts seemed a bit salty, but other parts were just fine. The fermentation flavor I got was less intense than the store-bought types, but still prominent, with slightly different flavor notes, but definitely prominent, and not half-bad. I finished that cup and went back for more. Good stuff.

It’s the next day and I did not die in my sleep from improperly fermented cabbage, which encourages me to try this again. I now have some mason jars I got for $1.00 each, a technique that seems to work. I’ll have to try this again.

© 2012,

4 thoughts on “Kitchen Experiment: Making My Own Sauerkraut (With Step-by-Step Pictures!)

  1. I have been doing my own sauerkraut all my life in big amount(right now 3 gallons are sitting in my fridge) and decided to comment because I think you are doing some mistakes.
    Here is my comment on the Perfect health Diet blog about the subject: They discuss a lot of fermenting, check it out.

    “I have been eating fermented veggies all my life since my family eats it for generations. I tried your kimchi recipe, and sorry to say, it was not a hit , to put it mildly, – cabbage was too soft, not particularly tasty in general. I routinely make sauerkraut, fermented cucumbers, tomatoes, eggplants, recently added to it fermented salsa. I just want to add some tips from my experience.

    -It is better to add some carrots when you prepare fermented cabbage
    (one or two carrots per one cabbage head), and nothing else, but salt.( Use salt without iodine, because iodine can inhibit fermentation.) When it is ready, let it stand in a refrigerator for couple of weeks – taste will be better developed.

    -It is important to ferment veggies in relatively cool place, or brine may be bitter. I leaned it when I was making sourdough bread.

    -Fermentation occurs faster if you use some leftover brine as a starter. It doesn’t matter if brine comes from different fermented dish. I usually keep some starter brine in my fridge.

    -It is possible to ferment cooked veggies, like eggplants. Fermented eggplants should be cooked first in salted water, then some sauteed in olive oil carrots and onions are added inside of each eggplant through long-wise cut, raw garlic and celery are added, all get placed tightly in a jar, starter is added.

    -Fermented veggies are very good in winter salads. Here is the example – If you combine medium cooked beet (or contains of 1 can of canned beets, drained), medium cooked potato, one cooked carrot, 3 pickles (or 1 cup of minced sauerkraut), half of raw onion, one finely chopped celery stick, add some brine and olive butter or mayonnaise, you will get great side dish. It could be used as a potato salad substitute.
    -It is possible to mix raw things with fermented. For example, sauerkraut is much better mixed with raw finely chopped apple, green or sliced onion and olive oil.”

    Some additional remarks – you used a very bad slicer, it is possibly the worst. My recommendation – Mandoline Borner V-blade slicer, I usually buy mine on internet every 5 years, it is made in Germany , not very expensive and really sharp. After getting that thing your kitchen life will never be the same.
    Next – do not wash your cabbage and avoid getting chlorinated water into it because it challenges fermentation.
    Don’t bother with pressing shredded cabbage too much – just put it into some big pot or bowl, add salt and carrots and let it sit until you see it got decreased in volume and released some juice. Then put it tightly into container for fermentation, don’t bother to press too hard – it may reduce some crunchiness. Sometimes you will not get enough of juices to cover cabbage right away – just be patient,
    Place your jar into some bowl because fermentation may cause the juice escape.
    You do not need a special container to ferment your veggies, just make sure your cabbage is submersed all the time. People use to make and keep it in barrels.
    Do not worry about a mold, just don’t let your sauerkraut to ferment for too long outside of the fridge, no more than 3 – 4 days. If after a long time some mold will be present, it will be on the serface of the brine. It usually takes about 2 months or more to get into that stage. People just keep some cheese-cloth floating on the surface, if mold happens, cheese cloth with mold gets removed and washed.

    I am afraid I can write a book about fermenting veggies. Fell free to ask a question if you have some through my personal e-mail you will find in my profile or in comments. If something else comes into my mind, I will write more.

    1. Hi Galina,

      Wow – thanks for all the great advice as well as the link. My research on this topic shows that a seemingly simple process of fermenting cabbage is surrounded by many different opinions on how it’s done. The link also showed other nifty things that can be fermented.

      As to my experiment, I consider it a success because: 1) I didn’t die and 2) it actually came out edible and was pretty good, actually.

      Now I’ll have to experiment with this a little more – and your advice and that link will be good research for my next experiment.

      Oh – the mandoline? I bought it because it reminded me of a DeLorean car like the one from the movie ‘Back to the Future’ – I’m a guy, what can I say?



      1. The one I use is also a mandolin but a better quality one.
        Here is another super-simple recipe – just cut in veges a cabbage head(like 8 veges from one head) , cover it with a water until the cabbage pieces are covered, then drain that water into different pot, measure the amount, bring it to a boil, add any spices you want, salt in the amount of 1 leveled Tbs/pint, pour that brine over the cabbage, add garlic and chopped celery when it cooled down, discard a bay leaf if you used it, cover with a plate and a heavy object in order to keep cabbage under the liquid. In order to make a better-looking cabbage, add shredded carrots, slices of beets, or red cabbage. Leave it for fermenting for a 3-4 days in a cool room until brine testes definitely sour , put fermented cabbage into a fridge afterwards. It will taste better in a week, but you can eat it right away. You can make cucumbers the same way. Making fermented food should not be complicated. Don’t let it sit fermenting for a long time if don’t want to deal with a mold. Feel to sent me a e-mail if you encounter any problem.
        Somehow I didn’t receive the notification about your comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.